The Coffee Potter in Long Valley, New Jersey Celebrates Fourth Anniversary with New Coffee Subscription Benefiting Local Charities

September 9, 2022 (Published: March 26, 2021)
Geralyn and David Hickey, owners of Coffee Potter coffee shop in Long Island, New Jersey
Geralyn and David Hickey, owners of The Coffee Potter

For the past four years, The Coffee Potter has served as a sanctuary for people in Long Valley, New Jersey to enjoy terrific coffee, food and the company of their neighbors.

That was the goal of Owners Geralyn and David Hickey when they opened their new coffee house on March 16, 2017.

The couple learned how to open a coffee shop through our 7 Steps to Success coffee franchise alternative.

“We’re thrilled to congratulate Geralyn and David on four years of running a thriving independent coffee shop,” said Crimson Cup Founder and President Greg Ubert.

“We look forward to helping them grow their unique business in the years to come.”

Building a Coffee Business from the Grounds Up

The Coffee Potter Long Island New Jersey

To mark their anniversary, the Hickeys talked about how they grew their coffee business from the grounds up with the help of Crimson Cup.

“Our town was long overdue not just for a coffee shop but for a place where people could meet, connect with one another, and feel welcome,” said David Hickey. “Our mission is to unite our local community and connect its people.”

Geralyn Hickey gave credit for the coffee shop’s growth to customers, employees and relationships formed over the last four years – including the relationship with Crimson Cup.

“The bonds our staff have formed with our customers are truly precious to us,” she said. “We’ve been there for our customers as they married, changed jobs, had babies, dealt with illness and experienced both joy and loss. Our deep focus on relationships and loving our neighbors sets us apart.”

David said the company’s core values of Integrity, Quality, Kindness/Respect and Fun help the coffee house stand out in the local community.

“Our employees are an absolute differentiator for us,” he said. “They live and work by our core values, and our customers love our employees.”

Crimson Cup “Essential” to the Shop’s Success

The Coffee Potter Long Island New Jersey

The relationship with Crimson Cup has been essential to the shop’s success. “The resources Crimson Cup makes available to us, from marketing to equipment maintenance, have been invaluable,” Geralyn said.

“Everyone at Crimson Cup understands our business and wants us to succeed,” David added.

“They are available any time of day, any day of the week, if we have a question, a problem, or want to brainstorm an idea.”

For the Hickeys and over 150 local business owners in 30 states, the road to opening and running a successful coffee shop started with our 7 Steps to Success coffee shop franchise alternative program.

“As the coffee partner for The Coffee Potter and over 150 independent coffee shops in 30 states, we believe their success is our success,” Greg said.

The program takes its name and content from Greg’s book, “Seven Steps to Success: a Commonsense Guide to Succeed in Specialty Coffee.”

Crimson Cup consultants guide new coffee shop owners in writing a coffee shop business plan. They continue providing expert advice on site evaluation, equipment, training, marketing materials, menu ideas and much more.

A 7 Steps trainer with extensive experience stays onsite for a full week before the shop’s opening, and returns for grand opening celebrations.

David Hickey observed that adapting to change, especially over the last year, has been key to the shop’s continuing success.

“Crimson Cup has been so willing to support new ideas like our subscription program, making it so much easier for us to try new things,” he said.

Customers Rave about Crimson Cup Coffee, Local Pastries and Service

Crimson Cup continues to deliver coffee, coffee shop supplies, ongoing training and support.

Customers rave about the coffee, food and service. “Their coffee is amazing – every combination you can ask for,” said one Yelp reviewer. “I also love their pastries and their service is amazing.”

Our coffee ranks among the country’s best. Among many national honors, we won 2017 and 2020 Good Food Awards – which recognize the best tasting, most responsibly sourced coffees in the United States. We also earned a finalist place in the 2021 Good Food Award.

New Coffee Subscription Gives Back to the Community

Passion for helping their local community inspires the couple to give back.

“Our heart is to try to lift the burden of fundraising off local nonprofits, so they can focus their precious time and energy into the mission of their organizations,” Geralyn said.

“For example, we have a coffee subscription that supports local non-profits and charities,” she added.

“Each month, a portion of your monthly subscription goes to support a local non-profit or charity of your choice.

Their coffee business nourishes the couple’s relationship with each other and their neighbors. “It’s given us the opportunity to work together, and we are proud of contributing in such a big way to our community,” David said.


Greg said the couple’s focus on their local community made them a perfect fit for Crimson Cup. “Our mission is ‘Coffee+Community,’ and giving back is one of our core values.

“Independent coffee shops act as local community hubs where people gather to discuss ideas, do business and support one another,” he added. “They play an essential role in creating a vibrant community!”

Asked for advice for other prospective coffee shop owners, the Hickeys advised giving Crimson Cup a serious look. “We honestly don’t think we could have accomplished what we accomplished without them,” Geralyn said.

Visit The Coffee Potter

The Coffee Potter is open 7 days a week at 24 Schooleys Mountain Road in Long Valley, New Jersey. For the latest news and updates, follow their Facebook Page.

The Coffee Potter Long Island New Jersey

Comments are closed.